Elrathina (?)

Elrathina Trilobite from Marjum Formation

Name: Elrathina (?)
Trilobite Order Ptychopariida, Superfamily Ptychoparioidea, Family Alokistocaridae

Locality: House Range, Millard Co., Utah
Size: 15 mm
Stratigraphy: Marjum Formation, Middle Cambrian
Courtesy: Collected & photographed by Richie Kurkewicz
Remarks: This is an intriguing specimen found in a Delta, Utah Rock Shop. The label says it is from the Marjum Formation, but the species is found in the Wheeler Formationm as Elrathina wheeleri = Ptychoparella wheeleri. So is this a Ptychoparella, a new species, or a mistaken identification? According to James Cook: "I think it is a Ptychoparella. Elrathina is now considered a junior synonym. However, the only described Ptychoparella [=Elrathina] in Utah is from the Wheeler Shale,and is associated with Elrathia kingii. It has 19 segments, and is now called Ptychoparella wheeleri. So if this is a Ptychoparella it must be a different species, if it is from the Marjum Fm., and it appears to have fewer segments.
In Ca and Nv, Eoptychoparia and Syspacephalus are also now synonyms of Ptychoparella. So there seem to be quite a few species of it in the western US. It would not be very surprising to find another new one in Utah."